Bar Exam Sample Questions
(Modified 11/27/12)
The correct answer is (D), because more than a year has passed since Marcy’s public disclosure. The fact that she was unaware of the limitation until it was too late is of no consequence.
Show Answer to Question 2
The correct answer is (D), 8 dependent claims. This is the sum of 1 (Claim 2 depends on Claim 1) plus 1 (Claim 3 depends on Claim 1) plus 2 (Claim 4 depends on Claims 2 or 3) plus 1 (Claim 5 depends on Claim 3) plus 4 (Claim 6 depends on Claims 2, 3 or 5).
Show Answer to Question 3
The correct answer is (C). The newly claimed material composition does not fall into a range specifically covered by the prior art. So, a rejection based on anticipation is not appropriate. However, the composition is so close to the prior art composition that it may be considered as obvious to someone familiar with these materials. Once a patent examiner makes an “obvious rejection”, the burden shifts to the patent agent to either justify why the claim is not obvious or to drop the claim.